Shanna Mann graciously follows up “Want to be a hero? Start systematizing” with some practical guidelines -
The Gawande Method of Designing a Checklist
In The Checklist Manifesto by Atul Gawande, he gives advice on how to design a checklist. The main problem? It’s buried within the text. So I took the liberty of creating a checklist of my own. Ah, so meta.
Identify the “Pause Point”
The first thing you have to decide is what the trigger will be for you to consult your checklist. Where you put it depends on whether you have a Do-Confirm checklist or a Read-Do checklist
- A Do-Confirm checklist mostly memory-based, and when you’re finished, you consult your checklist to make sure you didn’t miss anything.
- A Read-Do checklist is like a recipe. You consult it, do the step, consult it, and move on to the next step
The Rules of Thumb:
- No longer than 5-9 items. After 60-90 seconds, people start short-cutting and the checklist becomes a distraction.
- Focus on the ”killer items.” They’re the most dangerous if missed but in spite of that they’re sometimes overlooked.
- Language should be simple and precise.
- The checklist should fit on one page, free of distracting fonts and colors.
- Use a sans-serif font and standard typography. ALL CAPS DO NOT MAKE IT EASIER TO UNDERSTAND.
The Golden Rule:
You must field-test your checklist.
Use Your Checklists Religiously
Gawande reports:
“When surgeons make sure to wash their hands or talk to everyone on the team, they improve their outcomes with no increase in skill. That’s what we’re doing when we use the checklist.” (emphasis mine)
Shanna Mann is kind of geeky about creating SOPs and checklists. She writes at Change Catalyst, and teaches clients to design systems from which to trust their instincts. No, the two are not mutually exclusive.


{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }
What about for longer checklists… the over 9 items?
I think Gawande would probably say that you need to break the process into segments. His examples in surgery seem to indicate they pause for the checklist at least a few times.
For my own process, (geek warning) I have a binder of SOPs which is basically a record of the systems I’ve taken the time to optimize. It’s heavy and unwieldy and isn’t used often, but I find the practice of recording and refining the system largely internalizes it. I imagine someday when I get a VA it will be worth its weight in gold, though.
The binder is supplemented by checklists on Post-its or short-cuts in my desk top. (I favor do-confirm checklists.)